


I duplicate-stitched like a mad thing over the weekend, and Sunday night I managed to finish the Fana pullover. I felt pretty lukewarm about this sweater right up until I started putting the snowflakes on it, and then I started to love it. Now that it’s done and I’ve been wearing it for three days straight, I’ve decided that it’s a real winner. It’s warm, it’s comfortable, it fits well, and it looks how I wanted it to look. What’s not to like?
Pattern: My own, based on the traditional Norwegian Fana cardigan in Priscilla Gibson-Roberts’s Knitting in the Old Way
Size: 38″ bust, 13″ to underarm on body, 16″ shoulder to shoulder, 19.5″ to underarm on sleeve, 8.5″ armscye
Yarn: ShibuiKnits Izu (55 percent mohair, 45 percent merino wool; 245 yds per 4 oz skein), two skeins each of Strawberry, Wasabi, and Ivory. This yarn is discontinued.
Yardage: About 1,350 yards
Source: Knit/Purl, Portland, OR
Needles: US 6 (4 mm) for body and sleeves; US 5 (3.75 mm) for ribbing
Gauge: 23.5 sts and 27 rows = 4″ in pattern
Notes: I started this project intending to knit a traditional Fana cardigan following Priscilla Gibson-Roberts’s Knitting in the Old Way, which includes percentage-system-style proportions and directions for a number of different traditional constructions, as well as descriptions and drawings of dozens of traditional garments accompanied by charts and guidelines for making your own. The book is a great resource, and when I started looking through it, I was charmed by the Fana cardigan, which I thought would be a good way to combine the three colors of Izu yarn I had in my stash. Once I got underway, however, I decided that the yarn wasn’t entirely suitable for the traditional Fana style — the I-cord edging in particular just didn’t look right — and I also realized that while there were certain elements of the traditional Fana cardigan that I liked a great deal, there were others that wouldn’t suit my personal sense of style. So I came up with this modified version, which suits me just fine.
I followed Gibson-Roberts’s instructions for a shaped-steek pullover, which is knit in the round from the bottom up to the armpits. At that point, some stitches are bound off for the underarm, steeks are cast on for both armholes (and, in my case, for the henley neckline), and the sweater is worked in the round up to the shoulders, with decreases at the armholes for the first 1.5″ or so. This results in an armhole shape that is the same as that used for set-in sleeves. Over the last 3/4″, I worked back and forth rather than in the round in order to add shoulder shaping to the front and back. Then I sewed and cut the steeks, seamed the shoulders together, and picked up and knit the arms downward in the round.
The resulting sleeve cap is a sort of hybrid of a set-in sleeve and a drop-shoulder sleeve: the sleeve itself has no shaping at the top, which allows you to work color patterns without interruption, but the armhole into which the sleeve is knit is shaped. Before blocking, the sweater bunched quite a lot under the arms, and I really didn’t like that. Now that the sleeves are blocked, it bunches somewhat less and in a way that doesn’t disturb the pattern as much. Still, I’m not sure I’ll be doing shaped steeks again.
The only real drama with this project was the result of a yarn shortage. I initially had about 1,200 yards of DK-weight yarn, which is cutting it close for a pullover in my size. Since I knit the sweater in the round from the bottom up, I was able to determine as I knit that I was not going to have enough of the red and green yarn to do the entire sweater in the striped pattern. This was okay, because I had been toying with the idea of doing the shoulders and sleeve tops with snowflakes — a design element of the traditional Fana cardigan. Implementing that plan required a second ball of white yarn, which I was able to order from Knit/Purl. (I believe that the owner of Knit/Purl is also the person who launched ShibuiKnits. Izu was a ShibuiKnits prototype that was discontinued and replaced with ShibuiKnits Merino Kid. The remaining unsold stock of Izu yarn is still being sold at Knit/Purl as a store-brand yarn, it seems.)
I split my remaining yarn in half before knitting the sleeves, so I was able to keep an eye on how much I had left as I worked my way down to the cuffs. It turned out that I had enough red, but not enough green, to do the cuffs, so red they are. I was initially really unhappy with this outcome, because I didn’t like how the red and green cuffs clashed when I had my arms down at my sides. The effect was a little too Children’s Toy Primary Colors for me. When I added the snowflakes, however, I decided to put green ones on the body and red ones on the sleeves. This had the effect of matching the snowflakes to the cuffs on both the body and the sleeves, thus creating a nice balance that neutralizes the effect that made me so unhappy.
I duplicate-stitched the snowflakes last, which turned out to be a good decision, because I had so very little yarn remaining that I needed to conserve it and plan those snowflakes carefully. The red snowflakes on the sleeves are slightly smaller than the green ones on the body, which saved me a bit of yarn and allowed them to fit into the available space. After I finished the final green snowflake, I was left with about 2″ of green yarn to weave in. I did better with the red: I had about 18″ left when I finished the red snowflakes. It was tight, folks, but I made it.
I could have stretched the yarn supply further had I made this sweater more close-fitting, as I normally do, but I was convinced that this construction and pattern would look best if it was just a bit oversized, so I built in about 3″ of positive ease. I’m glad that I did, because the fit seems just right, and I think a tighter sweater would have been less comfortable and less flattering.
I found the buttons for this sweater at As Cute as Button. They are pewter, which is traditional for Fana cardigans, and they’re about 5/8″ in diameter. I only had to order two sets of buttons this time to get it right — the first ones were too small. Unfortunately, the buttonholes are a bit gappy. I haven’t had this problem before, maybe because my earlier buttonholes were all done in garter stitch, rather than ribbed, bands. I’m planning to reinforce the edges with buttonhole stitch, which I hope will solve the problem.
This is the fourth sweater in my planned Fall/Winter 2007 design collection. If you look back at the original set of swatches, you’ll see that I was going to use this yarn in a slipped-stitch pattern. The sweater you see here is a far cry from the one I had planned, but going with the flow is part of the fun of designing your own sweaters!
Earlier posts about this sweater are here, here, here, and here. Oh, and the hat in the pictures is hand-knit, but not by me. My grandma made it for me a long time ago.